Tag Archives: National Journal

Rock the Vote poll shows young adults are not wed to Obama

A new poll by Rock the Vote of 1,000 18-29 year olds shows young adults engaged, but more cynical than two years ago. The top issues they want Congress to focus on are jobs and the economy, improving education and lowering its cost, and lowering the deficit and improving health care. Here’s a rundown of some key findings. The margin of error is 3.5%.

More young people are moderates and Democrats

  • Political persuasion: 41% are Democrats, 33% are Republicans, and 26% are Independents
  • Ideology: 24% identify as liberal, 39% as moderate, 29% as conservative.

The “ideology” stats line up with Neil Howe’s findings that this generation of Millennials are staunchly conventional. Three-fourths are either moderates or conservatives in the above poll.

Many (40%) believe the country is headed in the wrong direction, but there are sharp distinctions by race.

  • Only 30% of whites believe we’re headed in the right direction, but 63% of blacks and 51% of Hispanics believe we’re on a good course.
  • Those with less education were more likely to say country is headed in wrong direction.

The differences by race line up with the latest findings of the Heartland Monitor Poll, which finds that blacks and Hispanics are much more satisfied with Obama’s performance and are more optimistic about the future. A recent study on happiness finds that black-white gap in happiness is narrowing, because of gains among blacks.

The idealism of the 2008 campaign is wearing thin.

  • 37% disapprove of what Obama has done during his first two years in office.
  • About 60% say they are more cynical about politics than they were two years ago.

Young adults are still largely optimistic about their own futures.

  • 68% of whites, 82% of blacks, and 81% of Hispanics think they will be better off financially than their parents. (There were no sizable differences in this outlook by education, but more Democrats than Republicans or Independents are so assured.)
  • About 80% of young adults still believe they have the power to change the country.

The racial differences are quite striking, as is the fact that there are few sizable differences by education, which is usually the case. I don’t know what to make of the findings, other that to wonder whether the white middle class is really pinched and hurting. However, the black and Hispanic middle class should be equally pinched, yet they’re more optimistic toward the future and their potential earnings. Interesting…

I’m also encouraged by their belief in collective power. That they believe as a generation they can change the world is a refreshing shift from the deeply cynical views of their older GenX siblings (who had a point, I might add).

But there’s signs of cracks in that optimism.

  • 77% are concerned they won’t find a job that pays enough to be comfortable
  • About 80% worry they won’t be able to save enough for a house or for retirement (this worry heightens with age).
  • 70% are concerned they won’t find a job they enjoy.
  • 42% worry they will have to move back home with their parents. Even 38% of college graduates worry about this. (Higher shares of blacks and Hispanics worry about this.)

Given that about 6 in 10 think they’ll be better off than their parents (above), these numbers are puzzling. Maybe it’s immediate hurt versus long-range hope.

A ranking of their biggest concerns looks like this:

  • jobs and economy: 54% rank it first or second on the list of concerns
  • quality of education and its costs: 29%
  • the high federal deficit: 23%
  • health care: 23%
  • immigration: 14%
  • Afghanistan: 11%
  • gays rights/abortion rights: 11%
  • environmental concerns/global warming: 10%

For this generation, the most important education policy is improving elementary and high school education (44%). Next on the list is college affordability (38%). (Interesting that a larger share are more concerned with better education at the lower ends than the cost. You’d never guess that from the media stories.)

The most important energy policy is reducing our dependence on foreign oil (45%) followed by investing in new technology jobs (40%). 15% rank climate change as their biggest energy concern.

The most important economic policy is job creation (32%) followed closely by the high national debt (31%). More affordable job training and post-secondary education ranked third (23%), and 14% put cutting taxes at the top of their list for economic policies. (They’ve been listening to their parents complain about the budget and high taxes, I’m betting.)

All in all, some interesting findings that politicians could do well by heeding. This generation is much more committed to the voting booth than their older siblings. And they have good reason to go to the polls: they’re the army grunts of this recession: first killed on the battlefront of layoffs and firings.

Is college still worth it?

Are we reaching a point where people are questioning the value of college just as we need graduates the most?

I was in Washington a couple days ago for work and stopped by the National Press Club to hear a press conference on the Millennials. Ron Brownstein, Tom Wilson, chairman of Allstate, and others have done a fantastic survey (read: very reliable) called the Heartland Monitor Poll, on how young adults are faring in the recession. The survey is a joint project with the Atlantic and the The National Journal.

Being the data wonk I am, I ate it up. There’s tons of content to absorb, but this one caught my eye. When asked whether a four-year degree is a ticket to the middle class, only 46% said yes. (The survey was of young people aged 18-29. This question was asked of those with degrees, either still in school or working.)

That’s a serious crack in the dike on the education front. I looked back to the Network’s book, On the Frontier of Adulthood, to see if we had any similar data on past generations to compare against. There’s nothing exactly comparable, but one of the chapters looks at changing attitudes using data from the General Social Survey, conducted by National Opinion Research Center.  This question gets at the public’s confidence in education. That’s probably getting close to this notion of “is it worth it?”

Back in 1973, about 40% of young adults aged 25-34 had  “great deal” of confidence in education (this could be higher or lower education). By 1997,  that had dropped to 23%. The biggest drop occurred between 1973 and 1985 and leveled off after that.

Part of this is an overall decline in our confidence in big institutions in general, and certainly the public schools’ demise plays into this falling confidence. But it does seem to offer a hint at a trend toward a growing suspicion of whether our educational systems are doing their job.The Heartland Monitor Poll question just adds another level to it.

For the longest time, our colleges and universities were the beacon to all, and we offered arguably the best higher education in the world. But now a crack might be appearing. A crack that started with a declining trust in educational institutions generally might indeed be spreading to the seemingly invincible Harvards, Smiths, Northwesterns, and University of Californias.

Certainly cost is playing into this question, especially at those high-end schools. But I do think there’s more to it than that. I suspect that universities are grappling with a very real question–a question that is even more pertinent in a recession. That question is whether what they’re teaching is what leads to jobs (to pay off those bills). That question is an about-face for most colleges. Traditionally, colleges have been mind-expanding four-year interludes where you broadened your horizon and read the great books, grappled with philosophical questions, learn to think critically about life, and, well, mature. But when the price-tag creeps up into the $40-$50,000 range, that’s a pretty expensive hiatus. I hate to come down on the side of practicality this hard, but I think people are beginning to wonder–is it worth it if I don’t come out with “real” work skills? (My friend Mc-Arty has a great blog about her experience with an MFA in creative writing!)

The second part of the Heartland survey question was this: Do the responsibilities of my job frequently require me to use the skills and knowledge I gained through my education? 55% said no.

Food for thought.

Granted, the kids were in the beginning of their careers and no one at the bottom end of the totem poll sees the connection yet between their jobs and the education.  And believe me, not having a degree will show up pretty fast in the paycheck. But public perception is a powerful thing, and there’s often a grain of truth to it. So I think we should start really asking our colleges and universities what it is they’re preparing this generation for while they take their money. I doubt any other business could get away with failure rates as high as 40% (the share of freshmen who will drop out of college before finishing) while still raising rates.

The economy of the future requires higher education. But it also requires a dose of pragmatism. We need engineers, biochemists, and computer scientists if we are to shove this aging economy into the “green” future. It seems we’re at the same point the country was 60 years ago coming out of the war, and facing a retrenched economy that had shifted from agriculture to factories. Then we needed scientists and engineers, and we trained them masterfully. (Tom Wolfe has a fantastic essay, “Two Young Men Head West,” in Hooking Up about an engineer from Grinnell College in Iowa who in the early 1960s went west  to California to what would become Silicon Valley.)  Today, Obama is calling for a retrenchment of science, technology, engineering, math (STEM in education lingo), and none too soon.

The doubt about the value of education is on the street. But we can’t retreat from education. We just have to retool it.

National Journal Magazine – Children Of The Great Recession

National Journal Magazine – Children Of The Great Recession.

A great article by Ronald Brownstein and crew on what young people today are facing as they head into a workforce struggling to recover from the Great Recession.

Here’s some tidbits:

  • Their great expectations are colliding with diminished circumstances.
  • For many others the working world has become an inscrutable maze of part-time jobs, temporary gigs, and full-time positions that abruptly dissolve into layoffs.
  • Many young people are stuck at the bottom of the jobs escalator as boomers at the top can’t retire because their 401ks tanked. Those who have managed to get on the escalator are often not rising smoothly. They might gain a job, lose it, and fall back several steps–or off altogether.

But they’re an optimistic bunch.

  • Many are flocking to public service, like AmeriCorps, the Peace Corps, and Teach for America
  • Others are thinking like entrepreneurs as “the gig” economy forces them to be nimble on their feet. At Steadfast Associates, a group of Millennials has created a business that works as a hub for freelancers in the arts.

But in the end it’s a tough road ahead. As Robert Reich says of this predicament: “It’s a social problem if young people, fresh out of school…can’t get into the labor force and have to sit around for a year or two or more.”